Post by Joaquin on Oct 29, 2015 22:53:03 GMT
Ok guys. I’m going to warn you. This is gonna be a bit long lol. Since you guys are all talking about how this game was hard on you, I’d like to talk a bit about that. This game was hard for a lot of people and it was hard for me too. We all have our reasons that this game was very tough for us and I really appreciate all three of you elaborating on that and I totally respect your reasons but it made me think about how this game was VERY hard for me too. Probably the hardest game I’ve played just in terms of the psychological element. I was just gonna make a little congrats paragraph, ask a question or two, and cast my vote but this (as well as some of your other answers and OSs) got me thinking. So I want to talk a bit about that.
When I decided to reach out to JW to play this game, I had a goal to confess more, be more active (since I wasn’t as busy anymore and not in another game this time), and get far. It was a way to redeem myself and to show JW that everyone has off times but that I’m not the inactive spawn of Satan he probably thought I was. I felt when I was eliminated prejury at a (bullshit) “random tribal council” that I had done that. I had confessed a lot in those first few rounds, was set up fairly well had I gone to an ACTUAL tribal, and was dedicated. I was content and I really didn’t have much a plan to return to the game even though the offer was out there. Then as the game went on and I wasn’t in another game, I wanted to get back in to be able to play and to help Keri and Chris (Sierra & Matty) who I knew were struggling and had really only survived thanks to a solid tribe that allowed them to #cochrekt the competition for a few rounds.
So I decided to come back in, did the challenge (which I assumed I had to do to get back in), and Matty made sure to give up immunity to get me back in. I knew as someone who had already been eliminated, it was unrealistic to think I would be rewarded by a jury had I made it to the end so I decided on a certain path of action. I would eliminate the people who frankly did not deserve to be in and who I wasn’t a huge fan of in this particular game and when I felt the numbers were somewhat even and Keri, Chris, Zach, Grant, etc. all had an equal shot at the win, I would bow out and ask to be voted out. Let the best fight it out. But then we found the Life Saver and didn’t want to waste it on the likes of Coach which was understandable. So against my emotional intuition but admittedly pissed off at having been voted out and seeing Courtney go, I voted out Alec. At that point, I was in too deep because there was going to be no real shot at equalizing the numbers anymore. So I decided to go true Joaquin and play for Matty and Sierra. I couldn’t win so why not? Then the next round I came up with a plan that I loved. Ian wanted to flip and implied that Nay wanted to flip. I made sure Ian and Nay were gonna vote Coach. I also wanted Steph and Sierra Dawn to vote Coach. He would go with 4 votes and then myself, Sierra, and Matty could vote for Brandon to force the tie against Fabio, Brandon, and Coach. We could take out Brandon on the revote and then we had officially decimated the other side (except for Fabio which I had no intention of doing).
But Sierra Dawn fucked it all up because Ian was “a looser.” Ian (who after #Englishgate, I thought was a goat for me to win and who now wanted to work with me) left. I now reassess the situation. I wanted Sierra Dawn out for many reasons and I began to realize that if I could get Steph and Nay to the end, I could potentially win against two people who had ACTUALLY played a worse game than me. So I manipulated Matty into voting out Sierra Dawn (one of my proudest moments (not the manipulation part) this game especially after her reaction when I got to Ponderosa) and she left. Now I was a little pissed at Sierra. After all I had done for her all game, she was mad that I dared to do something that didn’t directly benefit her and benefitted myself for once. And she retaliated by targeting me in Majority Rules and by not taking me to the Treasure Trove (after I had taken her the round before and didn’t take Nay who had taken me). I was pissed but she had immunity. So I had a choice. Going with my F3 plan, I couldn’t vote out Steph or Nay and I figured after all my promises, it would be suicidal jury management to vote out Fabio. That left Matty. Now I don’t get emotions a ton ngl. I have them but I can be a bit of a socially awkward guy and I think very strategically (both in my real life and in ORGs) so I don’t realize that blindsiding my best friend in ORGs the round after I asked him to vote out SD as a favor to me is the best thing to do on an emotional level. Long story short, there was a very long talk that basically ended with it being clear that if I voted him out, he and Sierra would be rather bitter jurors and would not be voting for me. I then realized that without their votes (which I was banking on), I had 0 shot at winning. Now I have common sense. If I can’t win there’s no point of going to the end, especially at the cost of hurting Matty, Sierra, and Fabio by voting them all out. So I decide to essentially bow out. I voted against Steph (hoping she would go) and then I planned on asking to be voted out at 5. But the tie was forced and I thankfully went in the rock draw. So suffice enough to say, this game was by no means easy on me either.
Now that I’ve talked about me, I want to get into why (keeping all this in mind) I have a problem voting for each of you. I want to make that clear. At this moment, I don’t plan on casting a vote. So let’s start this off with Nay. My problem with you is that I don’t think you played this game very well or really did much of anything. If what you say is true about the Reynold vote, then I can’t help but have respect for that because that was a great move but your excuse as to why you then didn’t continue to make moves is weak. You didn’t want to make yourself too visible because you wouldn’t get to the end? You’re sitting next to THE most visible player in the game so that’s a very weak excuse to just stop making good moves like the Reynold boot. Which you can argue you didn’t but I think it’s clear that what I’m saying is true. You really didn’t do much else premerge after the Reynold boot but be a blind number for the Warriors pregame. Then, at the merge, you did remained a number for the Warriors crew and didn’t really hatch many plans yourself. You also unnecessarily led the minority alliance on three times. Your reasoning for the Courtney lie makes sense. It’s still lying to the minority which is risky but it is reasonable. But you didn’t stop there. During the Alec round, you told me that you wanted to flip and vote Coach. In fact, you talked to me for 2 hours about flipping but kept it vague so I asked directly if you planned on flipping. You didn’t respond for a half hour. With about 10 minutes left before the deadline, I asked again and finally you told me you were going to “probably vote in a different direction.” Lying up until 10 minutes before the deadline is still leading us on. Then again the next round, you lied to Ian and had him believe you were willing to flip with him which is why I accounted you in the split plan. At this point there was literally no reason to lie to us and the only reason Coach left was because Brandon voted Ian. You led us on 3 times. Then you were a vote for the Sierra Dawn round but you did not “manipulate” me into voting that way by taking me to the trove. I knew Sierra Dawn was a threat to win and a threat to me personally so I voted the way I did on my own. And the only reason I wanted to work with you was because I thought I could beat you (which I admittedly couldn’t because of bitter jurors and a few people’s lack of care/respect for the game). So that was MY move. You didn’t “manipulate” me. Then the rocks round where you needlessly risked your life AND performed some of the worst jury management I’ve ever seen (and that’s including Tyler in Twisted 4 LOL; inside jokes). You literally wished Fabio luck in the AIM chat and completely ignored me as if I was garbage. I was happy to get out because of the reasons I listed but you still knew I was going to be on the jury and you still treated me very poorly on my way out for no real reason. Oh and you celebrated when I was out with “the cheers of the audience.” Then you voted out Matty who was someone you could beat, having read through Ponderosa, AND tried to take Fabio to the end who would’ve unanimously shut you out in a jury vote. You really were not responsible for a single boot in this game except for Reynold and maybe me (which was foolish because you could’ve beat me). I only have 1 question for you and despite everything I just said, I may still vote you. Why laugh at me on my way out at F6 knowing I would be a jury vote? You can also argue any point I made but that’s my question for you.
Steph. My main problem with you is on a personal level and so I won’t address it here since it doesn’t really pertain to the game and since you’ll probably take a lot of shit for it in that game. But as far as this game, you admittedly did not do much this game despite some early plans and you went fairly inactive. I think the comparison you made to Luanda Joaq is totally fair because you went inactive due to some factors that made it hard to play this game so you played more for Sierra to win which I get. Keri is pretty great and I did the same at one point. I do want you to know that it will be very hard to vote for you because of my problems with you on a personal/moral level but if Sierra and Nay leave me no choice, it’s what I’ll probably do. So my question is if you were the Joaq of TSG AS, why should I vote for you when you didn’t even want to vote for TSG Joaq yourself?
Sierra. This one is gonna be tough for many reasons. I didn’t really have a huge problem with voting for you coming in but I have 3 now. And I need them justified if you’re going to get my vote. I plan to vote out of my love/respect for Survivor which is why it’s tough atm to vote your way. My first issue with you is your lack of awareness of the game that took place around you. This one has developed as this FTC has gone on. A lot of what you said has just baffled me and game awareness is one of the most important things to me. It’s why I always ask my juror power rankings question because it’s hard to vote for someone who doesn’t have great game awareness. So my first question to you is to please justify a few statements I’ve taken from what you’ve said so far (listed below). My second problem with you comes from your lack of respect for Survivor which is one of the deciding factors in my vote. So my second question to you is if you had lost the tiebreaker at 4 and been voted out, who would you have voted for to win and why? My final issue with you is your lack of respect of me and everything I did for you in this game. Deny it if you’d like but I came back in with the sole intention of helping you equalize the numbers, not to win. When I realized I had a small chance to win and decided to play a little for myself, I eliminated a vicious person who had unnecessarily targeted me (despite me saving her ass with the life saver as well) and who couldn’t even be bothered talking to me in the game outside of checking who I was voting for. You subsequently alienated me like I was some kind of sociopath, totally disregarded what I had done for you including keeping you in the game on a revote where it was in my better interest to eliminate you, targeted me in Majority Rules, apparently had a plan to eliminate me that round if more people would be on board, and didn’t take me to the Trove after I totally screwed over Nay for you by not taking her the round before and taking you instead. I then LITERALLY sacrificed my game for you (and Chris) by going to rocks when it was in my better interest not to and getting myself eliminated and even here you continue to make statements as if I was some sort of untrustworthy scum not worth the dirt on your shoe because I eliminated Sierra Dawn. Not only was I your ally but I’m your friend and the way you’re treating me at this FTC is really disheartening. Oh and your hypocrisy. You have stated that you intended to go to the end with Matty and Sierra Dawn rather than Matty and I so after you guilted me into feeling like a douche for wanting to eliminate you and Chris you had every intention of doing literally the exact same thing to me. But you guilted me into feeling like shit for even considering voting you out with your holier than thou attitude when you were going to do the same thing to me. So my final question to you is why should I vote for someone who clearly has a total lack of respect for me as a player and as a friend? And why you think the hypocrisy you exhibited is perfectly acceptable? If you can’t clear up these three problems, I won’t be able to vote for you.
1. “Sierra Dawn, you really are one of my favourite people I've ever met in these games, and you were absolutely my rock for the entire time we were together.” (there were many people every round that went your way and were in your corner, not just Sierra Dawn)
2. “Joaq screwed SD at 7 with a view to force me to sink with her. He would not listen to reason and his illogical argument re: why she "needed" to go made it clear that he was going to come after me ASAP, likely with your help.” (I did have a plan to vote you out after SD but I want to be clear that I was very much not willing to do it until you started defending SD so much right after she had targeted me and it became clear that she meant more to you as an ally than I did. I thought you had a plan to go to the end with Steph and her over me which pissed me off tbh. I was close to you but that didn’t mean I had to defend your allies, especially after they target me.)
3. “my closest alliance (me-Sierra-Matty)” (REALLY?!?!)
4. “The point is, though, no one was falling on any swords for me.” (Regardless of the reason, I literally went to rocks next round instead of sending Matty, and you the next round, out and sent myself out.)
5. Your entire response in SD’s thread.
I want you all to know that this is very hard for me to do. I like all 3 of you a lot for various reasons but on a game level it is tough to cast the vote that JW wants me to cast and at the moment I truly can’t. So I want you to please not take my statements/questions as attacks. I know they seem harsh but I’m only trying to get to the bottom of stuff so that I can vote how I think is right. Please respond FAIRLY and don’t attack me back and turn this into a petty argument. Thanks.
When I decided to reach out to JW to play this game, I had a goal to confess more, be more active (since I wasn’t as busy anymore and not in another game this time), and get far. It was a way to redeem myself and to show JW that everyone has off times but that I’m not the inactive spawn of Satan he probably thought I was. I felt when I was eliminated prejury at a (bullshit) “random tribal council” that I had done that. I had confessed a lot in those first few rounds, was set up fairly well had I gone to an ACTUAL tribal, and was dedicated. I was content and I really didn’t have much a plan to return to the game even though the offer was out there. Then as the game went on and I wasn’t in another game, I wanted to get back in to be able to play and to help Keri and Chris (Sierra & Matty) who I knew were struggling and had really only survived thanks to a solid tribe that allowed them to #cochrekt the competition for a few rounds.
So I decided to come back in, did the challenge (which I assumed I had to do to get back in), and Matty made sure to give up immunity to get me back in. I knew as someone who had already been eliminated, it was unrealistic to think I would be rewarded by a jury had I made it to the end so I decided on a certain path of action. I would eliminate the people who frankly did not deserve to be in and who I wasn’t a huge fan of in this particular game and when I felt the numbers were somewhat even and Keri, Chris, Zach, Grant, etc. all had an equal shot at the win, I would bow out and ask to be voted out. Let the best fight it out. But then we found the Life Saver and didn’t want to waste it on the likes of Coach which was understandable. So against my emotional intuition but admittedly pissed off at having been voted out and seeing Courtney go, I voted out Alec. At that point, I was in too deep because there was going to be no real shot at equalizing the numbers anymore. So I decided to go true Joaquin and play for Matty and Sierra. I couldn’t win so why not? Then the next round I came up with a plan that I loved. Ian wanted to flip and implied that Nay wanted to flip. I made sure Ian and Nay were gonna vote Coach. I also wanted Steph and Sierra Dawn to vote Coach. He would go with 4 votes and then myself, Sierra, and Matty could vote for Brandon to force the tie against Fabio, Brandon, and Coach. We could take out Brandon on the revote and then we had officially decimated the other side (except for Fabio which I had no intention of doing).
But Sierra Dawn fucked it all up because Ian was “a looser.” Ian (who after #Englishgate, I thought was a goat for me to win and who now wanted to work with me) left. I now reassess the situation. I wanted Sierra Dawn out for many reasons and I began to realize that if I could get Steph and Nay to the end, I could potentially win against two people who had ACTUALLY played a worse game than me. So I manipulated Matty into voting out Sierra Dawn (one of my proudest moments (not the manipulation part) this game especially after her reaction when I got to Ponderosa) and she left. Now I was a little pissed at Sierra. After all I had done for her all game, she was mad that I dared to do something that didn’t directly benefit her and benefitted myself for once. And she retaliated by targeting me in Majority Rules and by not taking me to the Treasure Trove (after I had taken her the round before and didn’t take Nay who had taken me). I was pissed but she had immunity. So I had a choice. Going with my F3 plan, I couldn’t vote out Steph or Nay and I figured after all my promises, it would be suicidal jury management to vote out Fabio. That left Matty. Now I don’t get emotions a ton ngl. I have them but I can be a bit of a socially awkward guy and I think very strategically (both in my real life and in ORGs) so I don’t realize that blindsiding my best friend in ORGs the round after I asked him to vote out SD as a favor to me is the best thing to do on an emotional level. Long story short, there was a very long talk that basically ended with it being clear that if I voted him out, he and Sierra would be rather bitter jurors and would not be voting for me. I then realized that without their votes (which I was banking on), I had 0 shot at winning. Now I have common sense. If I can’t win there’s no point of going to the end, especially at the cost of hurting Matty, Sierra, and Fabio by voting them all out. So I decide to essentially bow out. I voted against Steph (hoping she would go) and then I planned on asking to be voted out at 5. But the tie was forced and I thankfully went in the rock draw. So suffice enough to say, this game was by no means easy on me either.
Now that I’ve talked about me, I want to get into why (keeping all this in mind) I have a problem voting for each of you. I want to make that clear. At this moment, I don’t plan on casting a vote. So let’s start this off with Nay. My problem with you is that I don’t think you played this game very well or really did much of anything. If what you say is true about the Reynold vote, then I can’t help but have respect for that because that was a great move but your excuse as to why you then didn’t continue to make moves is weak. You didn’t want to make yourself too visible because you wouldn’t get to the end? You’re sitting next to THE most visible player in the game so that’s a very weak excuse to just stop making good moves like the Reynold boot. Which you can argue you didn’t but I think it’s clear that what I’m saying is true. You really didn’t do much else premerge after the Reynold boot but be a blind number for the Warriors pregame. Then, at the merge, you did remained a number for the Warriors crew and didn’t really hatch many plans yourself. You also unnecessarily led the minority alliance on three times. Your reasoning for the Courtney lie makes sense. It’s still lying to the minority which is risky but it is reasonable. But you didn’t stop there. During the Alec round, you told me that you wanted to flip and vote Coach. In fact, you talked to me for 2 hours about flipping but kept it vague so I asked directly if you planned on flipping. You didn’t respond for a half hour. With about 10 minutes left before the deadline, I asked again and finally you told me you were going to “probably vote in a different direction.” Lying up until 10 minutes before the deadline is still leading us on. Then again the next round, you lied to Ian and had him believe you were willing to flip with him which is why I accounted you in the split plan. At this point there was literally no reason to lie to us and the only reason Coach left was because Brandon voted Ian. You led us on 3 times. Then you were a vote for the Sierra Dawn round but you did not “manipulate” me into voting that way by taking me to the trove. I knew Sierra Dawn was a threat to win and a threat to me personally so I voted the way I did on my own. And the only reason I wanted to work with you was because I thought I could beat you (which I admittedly couldn’t because of bitter jurors and a few people’s lack of care/respect for the game). So that was MY move. You didn’t “manipulate” me. Then the rocks round where you needlessly risked your life AND performed some of the worst jury management I’ve ever seen (and that’s including Tyler in Twisted 4 LOL; inside jokes). You literally wished Fabio luck in the AIM chat and completely ignored me as if I was garbage. I was happy to get out because of the reasons I listed but you still knew I was going to be on the jury and you still treated me very poorly on my way out for no real reason. Oh and you celebrated when I was out with “the cheers of the audience.” Then you voted out Matty who was someone you could beat, having read through Ponderosa, AND tried to take Fabio to the end who would’ve unanimously shut you out in a jury vote. You really were not responsible for a single boot in this game except for Reynold and maybe me (which was foolish because you could’ve beat me). I only have 1 question for you and despite everything I just said, I may still vote you. Why laugh at me on my way out at F6 knowing I would be a jury vote? You can also argue any point I made but that’s my question for you.
Steph. My main problem with you is on a personal level and so I won’t address it here since it doesn’t really pertain to the game and since you’ll probably take a lot of shit for it in that game. But as far as this game, you admittedly did not do much this game despite some early plans and you went fairly inactive. I think the comparison you made to Luanda Joaq is totally fair because you went inactive due to some factors that made it hard to play this game so you played more for Sierra to win which I get. Keri is pretty great and I did the same at one point. I do want you to know that it will be very hard to vote for you because of my problems with you on a personal/moral level but if Sierra and Nay leave me no choice, it’s what I’ll probably do. So my question is if you were the Joaq of TSG AS, why should I vote for you when you didn’t even want to vote for TSG Joaq yourself?
Sierra. This one is gonna be tough for many reasons. I didn’t really have a huge problem with voting for you coming in but I have 3 now. And I need them justified if you’re going to get my vote. I plan to vote out of my love/respect for Survivor which is why it’s tough atm to vote your way. My first issue with you is your lack of awareness of the game that took place around you. This one has developed as this FTC has gone on. A lot of what you said has just baffled me and game awareness is one of the most important things to me. It’s why I always ask my juror power rankings question because it’s hard to vote for someone who doesn’t have great game awareness. So my first question to you is to please justify a few statements I’ve taken from what you’ve said so far (listed below). My second problem with you comes from your lack of respect for Survivor which is one of the deciding factors in my vote. So my second question to you is if you had lost the tiebreaker at 4 and been voted out, who would you have voted for to win and why? My final issue with you is your lack of respect of me and everything I did for you in this game. Deny it if you’d like but I came back in with the sole intention of helping you equalize the numbers, not to win. When I realized I had a small chance to win and decided to play a little for myself, I eliminated a vicious person who had unnecessarily targeted me (despite me saving her ass with the life saver as well) and who couldn’t even be bothered talking to me in the game outside of checking who I was voting for. You subsequently alienated me like I was some kind of sociopath, totally disregarded what I had done for you including keeping you in the game on a revote where it was in my better interest to eliminate you, targeted me in Majority Rules, apparently had a plan to eliminate me that round if more people would be on board, and didn’t take me to the Trove after I totally screwed over Nay for you by not taking her the round before and taking you instead. I then LITERALLY sacrificed my game for you (and Chris) by going to rocks when it was in my better interest not to and getting myself eliminated and even here you continue to make statements as if I was some sort of untrustworthy scum not worth the dirt on your shoe because I eliminated Sierra Dawn. Not only was I your ally but I’m your friend and the way you’re treating me at this FTC is really disheartening. Oh and your hypocrisy. You have stated that you intended to go to the end with Matty and Sierra Dawn rather than Matty and I so after you guilted me into feeling like a douche for wanting to eliminate you and Chris you had every intention of doing literally the exact same thing to me. But you guilted me into feeling like shit for even considering voting you out with your holier than thou attitude when you were going to do the same thing to me. So my final question to you is why should I vote for someone who clearly has a total lack of respect for me as a player and as a friend? And why you think the hypocrisy you exhibited is perfectly acceptable? If you can’t clear up these three problems, I won’t be able to vote for you.
1. “Sierra Dawn, you really are one of my favourite people I've ever met in these games, and you were absolutely my rock for the entire time we were together.” (there were many people every round that went your way and were in your corner, not just Sierra Dawn)
2. “Joaq screwed SD at 7 with a view to force me to sink with her. He would not listen to reason and his illogical argument re: why she "needed" to go made it clear that he was going to come after me ASAP, likely with your help.” (I did have a plan to vote you out after SD but I want to be clear that I was very much not willing to do it until you started defending SD so much right after she had targeted me and it became clear that she meant more to you as an ally than I did. I thought you had a plan to go to the end with Steph and her over me which pissed me off tbh. I was close to you but that didn’t mean I had to defend your allies, especially after they target me.)
3. “my closest alliance (me-Sierra-Matty)” (REALLY?!?!)
4. “The point is, though, no one was falling on any swords for me.” (Regardless of the reason, I literally went to rocks next round instead of sending Matty, and you the next round, out and sent myself out.)
5. Your entire response in SD’s thread.
I want you all to know that this is very hard for me to do. I like all 3 of you a lot for various reasons but on a game level it is tough to cast the vote that JW wants me to cast and at the moment I truly can’t. So I want you to please not take my statements/questions as attacks. I know they seem harsh but I’m only trying to get to the bottom of stuff so that I can vote how I think is right. Please respond FAIRLY and don’t attack me back and turn this into a petty argument. Thanks.